What is Constructive Discharge?

Attorney advertisement by Edwin Aiwazian of Lawyers for Justice, PC, headquartered at 410 Arden Avenue, Glendale, CA 91203

Constructive discharge, also known as constructive termination, or constructive dismissal, occurs when an employee resigns due to intolerable working conditions created by the employer. Under California employment law, the working conditions must be so severe that any reasonable person in the same situation would feel compelled to quit. Essentially, even though the employee technically resigned, the law views the situation as a forced termination because the employer made the workplace unbearable.

A constructive discharge case can include a variety of situations, including severe workplace harassment, retaliation, employment discrimination, or drastic changes in work conditions. However, not every uncomfortable or challenging work environment qualifies. The key factor is whether the employer’s actions were illegal or violated public policy, and whether they created conditions that were intolerable to the point that a reasonable employee had no choice but to quit.

Legal Tips for Constructive Discharge in California

California law sets a high bar for proving constructive discharge. To have a successful claim, an employee must demonstrate several elements, such as:

Intolerable Working Conditions: The employee must show that the working conditions were so unbearable that any reasonable person in their shoes would have felt forced to quit, as well. This can mean an employer’s conduct shows severe harassment, ongoing discrimination, illegal activity, or retaliation for whistleblowing or complaints.
Employer Intent or Knowledge: The employee must prove that the employer either intentionally created intolerable conditions or knew about them and failed to correct them. For example, if the employer was aware of ongoing harassment or discrimination and did nothing to resolve the issue, that could strengthen a constructive discharge claim.
Violation of Public Policy or Law: Constructive discharge claims often succeed when the employer’s actions violate public policy or specific laws. For example, if an employer engages in illegal activity, such as wage theft or discrimination based on race, gender, or other protected characteristics, the employee’s resignation could qualify as them being constructively discharged.
No Reasonable Alternatives: Finally, the employee must show that there were no reasonable alternatives to quitting, such as transferring to a different department, or using internal reporting mechanisms to resolve the issue. If an employee resigns without trying other options, it may weaken their constructive discharge claim.

Conditions That May Lead to Constructive Discharge

In California, constructive discharge cases often involve:

Harassment and Discrimination: If an employee is subjected to severe and pervasive harassment or discrimination, they may have grounds for a constructive discharge claim. For example, racial slurs, sexual harassment, or ongoing hostility based on a protected characteristic can create an intolerable work environment.
Retaliation: If an employer retaliates against an employee for exercising their legal rights — such as reporting unsafe working conditions, filing a wage claim, or taking medical leave — they may exacerbate the chance for constructive discharge. Retaliation can include demotions, pay cuts, or creating a hostile work environment.
Unlawful Work Conditions: Constructive discharge can occur when an employer forces an employee to endure unsafe or illegal working conditions. This can include asking employees to engage in illegal activities, or failing to comply with workplace safety regulations.

Legal Remedies for Constructive Discharge

If an employee can prove constructive discharge, they may be entitled to the same benefits as a wrongful termination claim, or if they were wrongfully terminated:

Lost Wages: Employees can seek compensation for lost wages, including back pay and future lost earnings.
Emotional Distress: In some cases, employees may recover damages for emotional distress caused by the intolerable working conditions.
Punitive Damages: If the employer’s actions were especially egregious, the employee may also be entitled to additional damages designed to punish the employer.

How To Prove Constructive Dismissal

While the employee technically resigns under constructive discharge, the law treats the resignation as a forced termination, which could make it possible for employees to seek lost wages or emotional distress damages. To successfully pursue a constructive dismissal claim, several steps need to be followed.

1. Recognize the Signs of Constructive Dismissal

The first step is identifying whether your situation qualifies as constructive dismissal. Some common situations that may lead to constructive dismissal include:

Harassment or discrimination: Consistent mistreatment based on race, gender, religion, age, or disability.
Retaliation: Being demoted, underpaid, or harassed after reporting unlawful activities or asserting legal rights, like taking family leave or filing a wage claim.
Drastic changes to job terms: Significant pay cuts, demotions, or other changes to your job duties without your consent.

Remember, for a claim to hold weight, the working conditions must be so unbearable that any reasonable person would feel compelled to quit.

2. Document Intolerable Working Conditions

Proving constructive dismissal requires evidence of the hostile or intolerable conditions an employee faced. Before resigning, document any unfair treatment, policy changes, or negative behaviors that contributed to your decision, like:

Emails or written communications from supervisors or HR.
Witnesses: Co-workers who observed the mistreatment or drastic changes.
Records of complaints: If you filed complaints internally and no actions were taken to correct the issues, this strengthens your claim.
Pay stubs or employment contracts: Evidence that shows changes in job duties or pay without prior agreement.

The more detailed and organized your evidence, the stronger your case will be.

3. File a Formal Complaint

Before resigning, it’s essential to give the employer an opportunity to correct the situation. This typically involves filing a formal complaint through the company’s HR department. In this complaint, outline the specific issues you’re facing and request a resolution. An employer failing to take action can support your constructive dismissal claim.

4. Resign and Include a Detailed Letter

Once you’ve given the employer a chance to rectify the issues and nothing has changed, you can move forward by resigning. It’s important to submit a formal resignation letter that clearly outlines your reasons for quitting. Detail the intolerable conditions that made it impossible for you to continue working, and specify the dates and incidents. The resignation letter serves as additional evidence that your departure was not voluntary, but was forced by the employer’s actions.

5. File a Constructive Dismissal Claim

After resigning, file your claim with either the California Division of Labor Standards Enforcement (DLSE) or by reaching out to the employment attorneys at Lawyers for Justice, PC (LFJ). The DLSE claim should include all the documentation and evidence you’ve gathered to show that your working conditions were unbearable and that your resignation qualifies as constructive dismissal.

Hiring an experienced employment attorney is highly recommended for navigating this process and presenting a strong case in court.

Is Constructive Dismissal Illegal? – FAQ

can i sue for hostile work environment after i quit? Yes, if you leave your job, or were forced to resign, because of a severe hostile work environment, a court may view your resignation as evidence that the wrongful behavior was indeed severe and intolerable, thus being classified as constructive discharge.

is constructive dismissal illegal? Yes, and employees can their employers for constructive discharge.

what to do when you are being pushed out of your job? Follow the above guidelines if an employer fails to correct pervasively bad workplace behavior.

can a job force you to resign? If the workplace conditions are so bad that a reasonable person feels they cannot continue working there, then yes, it may be viewed that the job forced that employee to resign.

can you sue for wrongful demotion? If a wrongful demotion violates an employment contract, it may provide grounds for employment law claim.